The issue was referred to in the case of Dreghorn v HM Advocate 2015 SCCR 349, and the judges in the present appeal considered it necessary to remind all involved of their respective roles when questioning witnesses. Lady Dorrian added: “We accept that, to an extent, the matters in question constitute legitimate grounds for inquiry, but the ... WebArthur v HM Adv 2002 SCCR 796. Man killed wife. Although he claimed self-defence, there was wicked recklessness due to disregard for consequences. ... Lord Advocate's Reference (No 1 of 1994) Intervening act doesn't break chain of causation when considering supply of drugs. MacAngus v HM Adv 2009 SLT 137. ... Van der Schyff v HM Adv 2015 SCL ...
Criminal Law and Evidence Case summary - Studocu
WebBrodie v HM Advocate 2012 HCJAC 147; Toal v HM Advocate 2012 HCJAC 123; McNally v HM Advocate 2012 HCJAC 156. All unsuccessful appeals. Although these cases show the High Court has made clear that the dangers of dock identification should, in certain circumstances, be explained to the jury ... Dunbar v HMA 2015 HCJAC 22; Reid v HMA … WebIn doing so, they had acted within the bounds of their discretion and an appeal court should be reluctant to interfere with such decisions (Thomson v HM Advocate 2001 SCCR 162, Lord McEwan at para [16]; CWA v HM Advocate 2003 SCCR 154, LJC (Gill) at para [16]; Neil v HM Advocate, unreported, High Court of Justiciary, 20 October 2006, Lord ... hideout valley
Mens Rea - Mens Rea Notes - Mens Rea There are several
WebOct 7, 2024 · Begg v HM Advocate sub nom Dreghorn v HM Advocate [2015] HCJAC 69; 2015 SLT 602; 2015 SCCR 349; 2015 SCL 802. Bevacqua and S v Bulgaria (71127/01) [2008] ECHR 498. Black, Petr 1991 SCCR 1. Boudjlida v Préfet des Pyrénées-Atlantiques (C-249/13) ECLI:EU:C:2014:2431; [2015] 1 WLR 2407. Donegan v HM Advocate [2024] … WebThe Dreghorn family name was found in the USA, and Scotland between 1840 and 1920. The most Dreghorn families were found in and Scotland in 1841. In 1841 there were 11 … Web• RHW –v- HM Advocate 1982 SCCR 152 • the degr ee of culpability and r ecklessness which is r equired to cons titute the necessary mental element is high, and that it is of the essence t hat ther e should be criminal r ecklessness in the hideout\u0027s yy